Over the past few months, I've begun to think about
the question, "In the predominant culture (the United States, my culture)
today, what is the image of being transgendered today?" I'm not sure that
this is as easy a question to answer as it would appear on the surface.
This is something I've been thinking about since my
adoptive niece Erica, made a comment about the featured speakers and content of
the conference workshops at Trans Philadelphia Health Conference. Over the past
few years, the content of workshops and speakers reflect a trend towards those
who identify as "gender queers", particularly in the Northeast and
West Coast.
According to the National Transgender Discrimination
survey approximately 13% of people who were included in the survey identified
as gender queer. Those who identify as gender queer are much younger than the
general population obtained in the survey. 67% identified within the gender
binary of male or female. Another 20% identified themselves as sometimes living
as male and sometimes female, but still clearly identified with the gender
binary concept to a large degree. 71% were under the age of 44 years, so the
study does not accurately reflect the age distribution of transgendered people.
20% were in school at the time of this survey. It was also limited to those
with internet access, so there are some confounding variables to this survey.
In other words, the results cannot be considered statistically valid or reliable.
However, it remains the most important study on
discrimination transgendered people face in the United States conducted to date.
In my opinion, despite the limitations of the survey, it is the most accurate
reflection of the life experiences of transgendered people in the US today.
Individuals
who identify as gender queer appear to be heavily influenced by an extreme left
feminist ideology that is fashionable in academia at colleges and universities.
It is known as third wave feminism. They advocate the ideological belief that
individuals who identify with the gender binary schema are hurt by it as their
lives are limited and scripted by having to conform to either a male or female
identity. Instead, they argue, we must create a genderless society.
In October 2012, a Gallup Poll reported that a
survey conducted from June 1, 2012 through September 30, 2012 found that
approximately 3.4% of Americans identified as being transgendered. These are
very similar results as reported in several other surveys since 2006 and can be
considered a good estimate of the general population of the U.S. These surveys
have a much higher degree of internal validity and reliability of the findings.
It is a more difficult task to ascertain how the
culture perceives transgendered people. There are several ways of coming up
with a general idea. One can look at how transgendered people are portrayed in
the media such as in movies and television. Another way is to look at how
transgendered people are portrayed in news sources. A third is to look at the
programming presented at transgender conferences.
Curious to me, is the image that Jerry Springer
provides on his television show. I'm also surprised that someone as strongly
identified with liberal politics gets away with the way transgendered people
are portrayed on his show and that he is so revered by the left. He regularly
brings on the worst examples of transgendered people in our society. If one
watches his show, one would draw the conclusion that transgendered people are
promiscuous, adulterous, drug addicted and essentially shiftless people who
engage in outrageous low life behavior. I do not dismiss the thought that at
least some of what he portrays is staged, but I also think that some of the
people he has on the show are real people. How Springer gets a pass on this
from the transgender community is beyond me, but I see more far more attacks on
conservatives who make negative comments about transgendered people and I can't
ever recall anyone complaining about Springer. Yet he damages the image of transgendered people tremendously. Why is that? I wonder...
Another problem I see is very complicated and is a
conundrum with no easy solution. We have a very high rate of suicide attempts,
unemployment, addiction and alcoholism. Those of us who have been
disenfranchised by lacking an education because of dropping out of school are
also often marginalized and often end up working in the sex trades. I was very
fortunate that despite being physically and emotionally abused in school for a
significant portion of my high school years that I was able to endure that and
later a brief period of homelessness (directly related to being who I am) and
manage to overcome those experiences. I was fortunate to have overcome these
experiences and I know that it was only by the grace of God that this happened.
The majority of transgendered people are also people of color and in addition
to the burden of institutionalized racism, bear the stigma of being
transgendered.
Having said this, I clearly want to say this is not
an attempt to "blame the victim". People do what they do to cope with
being stigmatized. Transgendered people don’t have the same access to the opportunities
that people who are not transgendered have and they experience a much higher
rate of being victimized physically, emotionally and sexually.
Remember,
when you were in grade school on "career day" and the teacher asked
the classroom "What do you want to be when you grow up? No one is raising
their hands and waving them wildly exclaiming" I want to be an alcoholic
and addict when I grow up!!" or "I want to prostitute myself when I
grow up!!!!!"
But we do have a responsibility to overcome the
illness of addiction with treatment and 12 step programs, seek help for mental
health disorders such as anxiety, depression and post-traumatic stress
disorder. We do not have the luxury of just rolling over and giving up, as
tempting as that may seem at times.
I looked at the content of workshops offered
in recent years at transgender conferences as a way to understand how we are
portraying ourselves to the public. I'm not sure that this is a way of
discovering what the public's perceptions are, but based on the percentage of
workshop programming devoted to gender queers. I do know that they are a very
vocal and public image of the "transgender community", much as drag
queens and kings" draw a lot of attention and possibly could be a strong
influence on the perceived image we have by the predominant culture.
Another
element that influences the public image of transgendered people is something
that I have seen decried frequently in our community. That is the tendency for
transsexuals who have successfully transitioned to end their involvement in the
transgendered community. Their attachment to the broader transgender community
is often more tenuous than other transgendered people. They are often criticized
harshly for not "giving back" to other transgendered people who are
coming along and finding their own way on the long and winding road of
successfully transitioning. Because they "disappear" into the
predominant culture, the public has little context for these individuals in our
society and this further skews the public perception of transsexuals (as
opposed to transgendered individuals not including transsexuals). While this is
ultimately the goal of most transsexuals, it is not necessarily what is desired
by other transgendered people who have a strong attachment to the transgender
culture.
My interpretation of what this represents is that
the majority of transsexuals do not identify with other people considered to be
transgendered and they do not share the same sense of community with drag kings
and queens, cross dressers, gender queers, and other diverse identities that
consider themselves members of the transgendered community.
In my opinion, a transsexual who has managed to
transition and does not wish to continue being involved in the community has
every right to do so. She does not owe the community or others coming behind
her anything. Her sole responsibility is to herself. In the words of Oprah
Winfrey “… to live your best life...”
Because of my profession and my experiences as a
transsexual, I will remain active in the transgendered community to a large degree
to help individuals with their transition and in overcoming addictions and
mental health issues that we all too frequently have. This is a choice I make
voluntarily as a professional, not a personal responsibility.
This necessarily means that I will have less privacy about my identity than I desire,
but because of my special set of skills I will continue to make my skills
available to the transgender community.
These are just my observations. What do you think is
the image of the transgendered community and what are the reasons for this? I'm
very interested in your opinions and I hope you will share them!